The minute you take a bite, you can tell this pizza was made by people you KNOW exactly what it takes to make NEW YORK PIZZA. I was initially skeptical by the Best New York Pizza (name) because that's a strong statement. As soon as I smelled the pizza, I knew I was in for something I haven't REALLY had since my last visit to New York. The taste of Long Island, New York made me smile. Thank you guys. I will next come sit down and have dinner with Best New York Pizza - as their food looks amazing, too.

Excellent.

I am addicted to their pizza...but their meat calzone is to die for...one family zone will feed 3-4...outstanding food. Table service is so so, I was made to wait on more than one occcassion, while the server chated about her personal life. But it is still my favorite pizza/calzones.

Best of the Best. This place makes fantastic Pizza. No Kidding, I'm from New York and let me tell you, I've had some of the greatest Pizza in the world in Manhattan, and this place is equal if not better than most of them. This is the very Best of NY Pizza, from the authentic crisp crust to the truly unbelievable flavor. Delicious and truly AUTHENTIC!

Guest 99146 on March 25 was the EXTREMELY rude and nasty to the staff working that day. I have ALWAYS found all the employees to be extremely polite and professional. Caroline is ALWAYS sweet and extremely helpful to all customers....even the rude ones like guest 99146! Let guest 99146 go eat some cardboard pizza somewhere else....I will ALWAYS come back to where the BEST pizza (NY or otherwise) is....and especially because the staff is so nice!

This place has really good food, I will go here again in the future.

Why are you reading this review when you could be eating the Best Pizza in Tampa!Honestly, look no further for great pizza. You found it! I've been to a lot of restaurants in the Tampa bay area and of course I have my favorites. But when it comes to Pizza I only have one place that I call my favorite, there really isn't even a close second to this place. Best NY really is incredible, I don't think I've ever had such great service at resonable prices anywhere. I mean, if you go to Mcdonalds you expect to pay cheap prices and get cheap/non existant service (which 9/10 is true) If you go to Macaroni Grill you expect to pay expensive prices with great service (which can be a 6/10) But when you go to Best NY you get a flat 10 out of 10. The food is awesome, the prices are very reasonable and the service is top notch! My order is always ready and always cooked to perfection. If my wife would let me I would order it every night, luckly I can sneak in atleast 2x a week to get my fix!

I'm Impressed! Most of the pizza places I've been in the bay area are pretty much they same... just blah. I've tried several in tampa, Lutz, New Tampa, etc... and none of them have much to offer. Of course when a close friend recommended a "new" pizza place to me in Carrolwood, it would be the same as the rest... they all claim to be NY pizza, but really there not... That is until I stepped into Best Ny Pizza. The smell was incredible! I felt like I was home! Of course the smell doesn't mean anything if it doesn't taste good too. Well after getting my 1 Cheese Slice and 1 Pepperoni Slice I was in Heaven! The Garlic Knots.... INCREDIBLE! I can't wait to go again this week and try something else! Honestly, I don't think another Pizza place in the area has anything on Best NY Pizza. They really are the best, if you don't believe me, just go and try it yourself! I'll see you guys Friday Night! Thanks for bringing great Pizza to the Tampa bay area!Nancy Young

Unbelievable Pizza! I love green olives and ham pizza and couldn't find any pizza joint to make it. Found this one and it reminds me of home! This place is in speed dial on my phone.

I recently found the best place in Florida to get pizza. Best New York Pizza. It really was the best pizza I have eaten in a long time. The store was really nice and very clean. The service was great. The staff was very friendly and helpful. The food was even better. I especially liked the Sicilian pizza. The atomosphere was like being home, That's how they made me feel . Great food... Great service.... Great place...I highly reccomend it. I'LL BE GOING BACK FOR MORE....

The food here is great. However the customer service is less than unreasonable. The cashier/helper named Carol, was very rude when taking the order, and now days with the economy the way it is, you would think employees at service positions such as this would value, and appreciate the fact that they have an income. I work in a service industry and I know it is the number one priority to make the customer happy, and go above and beyond to make sure the customer is satisfied and will come back. Again the food was good, but I would not recommend dining in at this place because of the lack of customer service and friendliness my family received. I will never dine in at this restaurant again because of the inconsideration of just one employee, again in todays world, building repour with customers is a must to be successful. Hopefully the owner/manager of this location will stress this to the employees. Thank you NY Pizza for the food, but I was very disappointed with service.

INCREDIBLE! I can't get enough of this place! Just when I thought they couldn't do any better they add new appetizers that I just can't resist! Calamari, Boneless wings, Mozzarella Sticks and so much more! PLUS the Chocolate Cake and Cheese Cake Bites! WOW! I can't WAIT to see what they bring out next! This place is the only place I want to go to eat, prices are great, the food is fantastic and the staff is always so accommodating! I tell everyone about this place! If you haven't tried it yet.... well, you really should! 5 Stars or More for BEST NY PIZZA!

Absolutely the closest thing to real NYC Pizza...absolutely fabulous . The Lasagna is my personal favorite....coming from a displaced Manhattanite this is truly NY Pizza...."forget about it!" Too bad they don't deliver :(

The pizza is above average. I have tried their salads as well. Thoes are my favorite. The price range is a little on the higher side, but the quality is better than most. Their combo prices on meals are the best bet. 7 bucks for 2 slices garlic roll and can coke.

WOW Real NY Pizza in TampaSince January 2007, we have travelled the country, living fulltime in a motorhome, from Florida to Arizona to Oregon top Maine. At each stop we looked for NY style pizza. In some cases we were disappointed; other times just disappointed.While in the Tampa area, we decided to try Best NY Pizza. My wife was skeptical. Should we drive 20 miles just to be disappointed again? I convinced her to try it.Best NY Pizza is a winner. We ordered a pizza with extra cheese and pepperoni (for me) and veggie (for my wife).My wife enjoyed her pizza and I found my part to be fantastic: the flavor fo the sauce?so much cheese that it was a challenge to separate the slices?the thin crust that drooped when I tried to pick it up.It reminded me of the many times when I bought a slice of pizza on 86th street in NYC while on the way home from high school oh so many years ago

When you order the meat pizza it is truly a meat pizza. The 12' feeds me and my wife. I just wish they had a punch card deals on the small like they do on the large pizzas / best in the area

We love Best NY Pizza! This is the only place in Florida that we have found quality New York pizza in all these years. Its amazing, its the real deal, bottom line is its the only place to get great NY pizza anywhere in Tampa. Best NY Pizza is by far the best, its incredible. We don't go to any other pizza place anymore. The pizza is so good and authentic you'll feel like your home again. In fact my wife and I recently visited family in New York and believe it or not the pizza we had there was not as good as the pizza we get at Best NY Pizza right here in Tampa. Wow..... I wouldn't have believed it myself, but Best NY Pizza was actually better than pizza we got in Manhattan. If you know good pizza, I promise you will love it!

This place is amazing! I've been a long time customer now and I've never been disappointed! They are consistant which really makes a big impression! Plus they just expaned which makes it much more inviting. I loved it when it was just a small pizzeria joint, but now it's huge! Comfortable booths and plently of seating makes you feel like staying rather than going home to eat this increbilable pizza. Best New York Pizza, You are truly the BEST in Tampa... possibly even Florida!Thank you for being serving the BEST Pizza, Having the BEST Staff and overall just being the BEST!I recomend you to everyone (even if I don't know them.)See you Saturday Night!

Not bad. The pizza sauce was bland. The cheese, and dough were very good. I would go back. The place was very impressive looking, and clean. The staff was professional.

The food is the best.. The service is great....(not to mention the pretty girls working up front always makes my day)no other pizza joint could possibly do a better job