We apologize for the inconvenience

The people search feature on Superpages.com is temporarily unavailable. You can still search for people on yellowpages.com since Yellow Pages and Superpages are part of one company.

You will be automatically re-directed to People Search on yellowpages.com in .

REVIEWS write reviewWrite a Review

REVIEW SUMMARY

  • 5
  • 4
  • 3
  • 2
  • 1
4.5
86 Reviews
Rate this business!
First-classBetter than mostAbout what I expectedNot the worst...Disappointing
Share Review

Like this review? Share it on your social network to get the word out!

anonymous

11/28/10

My family and I just had dinner in Best NY Pizza's new dining room. I have to say that it was great! I enjoyed the Chicken Piccata and my husband loved the Marsala! The kids shared a 10" pizza which is always perfect. The servers are so friendly. While our server was away we had another server come up to us and ask if the kids would like coloring pages while we waited for our food. I thought it was great to see that all of the servers made sure each diner (not just their tables) were taken care of. Keep up the good work! We'll be back soon!

Was this Review helpful to you?0
N
nattattatter

11/03/10

review count1photo count0

I love the new dining room! Looks like they had a decorator do the job! New food is fab too! Love it. Can't wait to go back!

Was this Review helpful to you?0
anonymous

10/28/10

The new dining room is amazing and the new menu options available on that side are great too! I have to say that I was fearful of going in and trying the new dining room. I was expecting it to be packed. But right now, because it's so new, that's probably what alot of people are thinking,that it will be crazy busy. But it's not! We got seated right away, our server was great! I've never seen her their before, but she was very friendly and outgoing. She also made sure we had everything we needed! The new Pizzas of the world collection is very exciting! We tried the Polynesian Luau and we loved it! I can't wait to go back and try the rest! If you haven't gone yet, you should! I would try it before it gets too busy because this place is sure to take off and quickly! I have to say the best part of all this is that even though it's a new dining room and has servers the prices are the SAME! You can't beat that! Thanks Best NY Pizza! Keep up the good work! You are truly the BEST!

Was this Review helpful to you?0
anonymous

10/24/10

This place just gets better and better! The new dining room is amazing! They really out did themselves and the best part is that they DIDN'T raise the prices! The prices are the SAME! I'm amazed at that, most places will hike their prices up when they upgrade the littlest thing, nope, not Best NY Pizza! They really put their heart and soul, not only into their food, but into this place as well! I love the fact that I can now go there for a nice comfy dinner and have a nice relaxing atmosphere and not pay the price I would in a normal place (that really isn't that good compared to this place). Thank you Best NY Pizza, Keep doing what you are doing! You've got a customer for life!

Was this Review helpful to you?0
W
wdavis3778

09/03/10

review count219photo count0

As far as pizza goes they had excellent pizza and the staff was fast and friendly.

Was this Review helpful to you?0
L
LovelyLolaLa

06/21/10

review count1photo count0

Best NY Pizza is the best Pizza Place around! No one compares to them! I love their new website & actually the website is how I got here! I didn't even realize that they had this many great reviews! However, the last review made by "Mynotablememories" was just bogus! I mean really, how can you say you love everything about this place and than complain how they gave you something free but it wasn't what you wanted so there for the "Suckered" you? I can't believe that! I mean they don't have to give anything away for free! That is insane that someone would complain about getting a Buy one get one free offer! People have lost there minds! In anycase, Best NY Pizza never ceases to amaze me! With their friendly staff, GREAT Service & even better food this place is the BEST! The fact that the owner even responded is even better. That's Great Customer Service! I mean they were giving you something FREE & they have to apologize because you didn't read it right? Come on.. Your Still THE BEST!!!

Was this Review helpful to you?0
H
heather.polk

06/11/10

review count2photo count0

I love everything I've tried at NY Pizza! Which is why were were excited to get a buy on get on free coupon from the mailing list (one day only special)! I called them to order pizza and they said- it's dine in only- OKAY- we made special arrangement to go there... get up to the counter... they said, it's dinner menu only... OKAY- well, we ended up spending $41 on Lasanga and a pizza to take home for my husband. NO WHERE on the email coupon did it list these limitations- I felt like I got suckered into something even though we love the food- It was NO deal and I lost my respect for their customer service practices....

Was this Review helpful to you?0
H
heather.polk

06/11/10

review count2photo count0

I love everything I've tried at NY Pizza! Which is why were were excited to get a buy on get on free coupon from the mailing list (one day only special)! I called them to order pizza and they said- it's dine in only- OKAY- we made special arrangement to go there... get up to the counter... they said, it's dinner menu only... OKAY- well, we ended up spending $41 on Lasanga and a pizza to take home for my husband. NO WHERE on the email coupon did it list these limitations- I felt like I got suckered into something even though we love the food- It was NO deal and I lost my respect for their customer service practices....

Was this Review helpful to you?0
A
apjatac

05/19/10

review count1photo count0

A little over 2 years ago, I walked into your pizzeria and I knew immediately, I had finally found New York pizza in Tampa. I am a native of Tampa and was raised in Long Island, New York. I know great pizza! Your establishment reminded me of the pizza parlors in New York. Your staff is friendly, family owned right down to your dachshund. The pizza is heavenly! You take pride in what you do. This evening, I had a taste for pizza and after browsing through the many coupons and menus I have, I decided to go online to the Zagat ratings. I did not want just a pizza, I wanted the best! Low and behold, Best New York Pizza was on their list! Since my SUV is not working, I have not been to your restaurant in a long time but I know your pizza is the best I've had since leaving New York. Your pizza is made with the finest ingredients. In a word, delicious! It's true what they say, "when you've had the best, you forget the rest"! You truly deserve a 5 star Zagat rating!

Was this Review helpful to you?0
MelDugal

04/27/10

Provided by Citysearch
It doesn't get any better than this!!!!!

This place is amazing! I'm starting to live off this pizza! I go there for lunch atleat 2 times a week and than I always go back to get another pizza to bring home for dinner! The crust is perfect! It folds in half (like it's supposed to) and a little bit of grease runs down your arm! Reminds me of home! :) The sauce is incredible it has a hint of sweetness to it! The Cheese is just the right amount of gooey!

LOVE IT LOVE IT LOVE IT!

Was this Review helpful to you?0
anonymous

03/30/10

Wow! This place is impressive! My family and I went to this pizza place the other night, we've been here before but this visit was our best! I love the fact that on a busy Friday night that the owners are so involved! We actually had a very lovely women (who must have been the owner) come over to our table and welcome us! We only spoke to her briefly, but wow, what an impression that makes! That the owners care enough about their customers to make them feel like friends and their staff keeps the store running smoothly enough so they can mingle with us! Bottom Line.... This Pizza place has it all! The Best Food, Service, Atmosphere.. you name it they have it!Thanks for being one of the best local places around! We only come to you for our pizza needs now! -Shelly

Was this Review helpful to you?0
S
shoppingguides

01/04/10

review count1photo count0

Like so many of your customers, I came to FL from New York. Brooklyn to be exact. Throughout the year I have to travel back to NY for various reasons. The first thing I do when I get back is to come here and get a great slab or 2 of square Sicillian. As for the staff, I think they are all great and friendly. Although I think they are getting to know me by now. Keep it up everyone and Happy New Year.

Was this Review helpful to you?0
anonymous

01/03/10

I love this place! It really is the best. They are very consistant with the food. Everytime I go I get exactly what I expect... PEFRECTION! As for the customer service, what do people expect when there are new employees. Give them a chance! THEY ARE NEW! They will learn and become what everyone is used to. You can not honestly expect a new person to know everything about a place they just started working. I have encountered these new employees and have to say that they were nothing but nice and tried to do there best. I understand that they are learning and quite honestly it bothers me when some people complain about new people. We've all been there. Just remember what it's like to be new and give them a break. The food is to die for and overall this is the only place in Florida that I have found authentic NY pizza, great customer service and a warm and inviting place to bring my family. Also we love the new live music they have on Saturday nights! I only hope that they expand!!!

Was this Review helpful to you?0
anonymous

12/28/09

Great PIZZA !, Great SERVICE !. Great PLACE !!!! . It REALLY is the BEST New York PIZZA

Was this Review helpful to you?0
anonymous

12/26/09

I highly recommend this great pizza restraurant. From the food to their wonderful hospitality from the staff. There pizza is a deliouse slice of New York, I recommend all of them.

Was this Review helpful to you?0
anonymous

12/16/09

FANTASTIC ! , the Pizza is the Best in Florida. Its real New York Pizza. I havn't had Pizza this good since I moved to Florida 10 years ago. Highly Recommended, you deserve to give them a try.

Was this Review helpful to you?0
anonymous

12/09/09

Somewhat true about the staff, but the place is looking wonderful! I love all of the up to date things they are adding! Looks great, not to mention their pizza is amazing nevertheless! Keep it up!

Was this Review helpful to you?0
anonymous

12/09/09

I agree with the previous notes,The new staff is not as attentive and personal as the previous staff members.I hope they do not ruin the reputation of your good customer service and name because the pizza is excellent and they deserve to be called the best.I will continue to do watch for the staff members.

Was this Review helpful to you?0
anonymous

12/09/09

The food was really good, especially the specialty pizzas. Although I feel the customer service could've been a little more prompt and attentive. They have I noticed gone through some changes with their staff, hopefully the new ones will catch on quick. I was a little disappointed on my last dine in.

Was this Review helpful to you?0
anonymous

12/02/09

OMG! This pizza is heaven!!! I'm from up north so coming down here I didn't have high hopes since no one down here knows what a pierogie is or a proper cheesesteak. So my pizza expectations weren't exactly high either. My work had ordered pizza & instantly it was love. Definitely reminds me of back home & the pizzeria's that used to be splashed throughout the towns. This place is worth experiencing. Not only the pizza but the rest of the menu items are fabulous! Run don't walk!!

Was this Review helpful to you?0
DETAILS
General Info
Best NY Pizza is known for our top quality New York Pizza. Our Pizza is made from only the best & freshest ingredients. We prepare all of our ingredients on site daily! Our dough and sauce recipes are a valued family secret! We hand toss every pizza & each are cooked to perfection in a brick oven! Best NY Pizza is proud of it's commitment to serving the highest quality & Best tasting New York Pizza anywhere.
Extra Phones

Phone: 813-280-0766

Hours
Regular Hours
Mon - Thu:
Fri - Sat:
Sun:
Categories
Pizza, American Restaurants, Italian Restaurants, Restaurants, Seafood Restaurants
Payment Options
Location
Market Place North II
AKA

Best New York Pizza

Best NY Pizza Inc

Other Information

Parking: Lot, Private

Wi-Fi: Free

Bike Parking: No

Attire: Casual

Good For Family: Yes

Good For Groups: Yes

Good for Kids: Yes

Wheelchair Accessible: Yes

Cuisines: American, Italian, European, Seafood, Continental, Pizza

Alcohol: Beer, Wine

Takes Reservations: Yes

Outdoor Seating: Yes

Suggest an Edit
Data provided by one or more of the following: DexYP, Data Axle, Yext.