I don't think that old review from 2011 is talking about Gill's in Valparaiso, because these guys are great. I've been using them for seven years since moving to Valpo. Time and time again, they diagnose a "no repair needed" or a "less of a problem than you brought it in for," costing me less money over the years that any place that ever has repaired my car. When they do find a problem, they find a way to save money, they get it done well, and the repairs hold--I can't think of anything that needed two trips to get fixed. I have brought all kinds of cars to them--1974 Caddie, 2000 Ford, 2002 Chrysler, 2006 Kia, 2007 Audi, 2009 Honda -- no problem with any of these makes.

Not very nice or friendly, pretty pricey and just all around not a good service.