We apologize for the inconvenience

The people search feature on Superpages.com is temporarily unavailable. You can still search for people on yellowpages.com since Yellow Pages and Superpages are part of one company.

You will be automatically re-directed to People Search on yellowpages.com in .

Map of Shelter Island, NYMap of Shelter Island, NYExpand Map

Italian Restaurants in Shelter Island, NY

Refine
Sort by
Features

61. Pizza Works

Pizza Works

455 Boston Post Rd, Old Saybrook, CT, 06475

CLOSED NOW
YP
9 Years
in Business
Amenities:
Serves alcoholWheelchair accessibleOffers outdoor seatingGood for groups

62. Leon's Pizza

Leon's Pizza

41 Boston Post Rd, Westbrook, CT, 06498

CLOSED NOW

"If you are looking for good pizza, there are much better options. The dining area is small and cramped. The booths barely accommodate 4 adults. The prices are extremely high…"

Amenities:
Serves alcoholWheelchair accessibleGood for groups

63. Da Vinci's

Da Vinci's

42 E Montauk Hwy, Hampton Bays, NY, 11946

CLOSED NOW

From Business: Tastefully decorated Italian restaurant and pizzeria located in the King Kullen shopping center in Hampton Bays, NY. Open 7 days. Great food, with only the highest quality…

64. Pizza Plus

Pizza Plus

284 Shore Rd, Old Lyme, CT, 06371

CLOSED NOW
YP
30 Years
in Business

66. Fiore's Of Westbrook Pizzeria & Restaurant

Fiore's Of Westbrook Pizzeria & Restaurant

314 Flat Rock Pl Unit D103, Westbrook, CT, 06498

CLOSED NOW
YP
21 Years
in Business
Amenities:
Takes reservationsHas WifiWheelchair accessible

67. Baranda

Baranda

850 County Road 39, Southampton, NY, 11968

CLOSED NOW

From Business: Baranda Restaurant is OPENBaranda Restaurant is OPEN

68. Best Pizza & Dive Bar

Best Pizza & Dive Bar

2095 Montauk Hwy, Amagansett, NY, 11930

CLOSED NOW

From Business: Best Pizza & Dive Bar is a large format, casual bar and pizzeria with indoor and outdoor seating, a great nightlife scene, a pool table, and laid back vibe. Best Pizza & Dive…

69. Tillie's at Gurney's Montauk Resort

Tillie's at Gurney's Montauk Resort

290 Old Montauk Hwy, Montauk, NY, 11954

OPEN 24 HOURS

From Business: Tillie's is an American café serving fresh classic dishes and comfort food at Gurney's Montauk Resort. Open for breakfast daily, with ocean views.Tillie's is an American café…

YP
25 Years
in Business
Amenities:
Has Wifi

70. Uncle Joe’s Pizza & Parlour - The Hamptons Institution Since 1968

Uncle Joe’s Pizza & Parlour - The Hamptons Institution Since 1968

42 E Montauk Hwy, Hampton Bays, NY, 11946

CLOSED NOW

From Business: Founded in 1968 by “Uncle” Joe Sciara, Uncle Joe’s Pizza & Parlour in Hampton Bays, New York is one of Long Island’s oldest pizzerias and red sauce joints. The Hamptons…

YP
56 Years
in Business
Amenities:
Takes reservationsHas WifiServes alcoholWheelchair accessibleGood for groups

71. Gemelli Gelato of Hampton Bays

Gemelli Gelato of Hampton Bays

139 W Montauk Hwy, Hampton Bays, NY, 11946

CLOSED NOW

From Business: Our Gelato shop is located set back from Montauk Highway. We serve over 24 flavors of Gelato and Sorbetto. We also have a big selection of chocolates, coffee, and cold drinks.…

72. Pizza Palace

Pizza Palace

1283 Boston Post Rd, Old Saybrook, CT, 06475

CLOSED NOW

From Business: Our family restaurant has been a local favorite on the Connecticut Shoreline since 1977. From our award-winning pizza to our fresh seafood delivered daily and “the best fried…

YP
47 Years
in Business
Amenities:
Has WifiServes alcoholWheelchair accessibleOffers outdoor seatingGood for groups

73. Westbrook Pizza

Westbrook Pizza

1551 Boston Post Rd, Westbrook, CT, 06498

CLOSED NOW

From Business: Westbrook Pizza has become known as the staple in the small CT Shoreline town of Westbrook. Locals have been eating food from Westbrook Pizza’s original location dating back as…

YP
34 Years
in Business
Amenities:
Offers outdoor seating

74. TJ's Restaurant and Pizza

TJ's Restaurant and Pizza

735 Boston Post Rd, Old Saybrook, CT, 06475

CLOSED NOW

From Business: When you are here, you can enjoy dinner in our full-service dining room or a quick bite in our front seating area. Our selection of fresh salads, homemade soups, specialty…

YP
13 Years
in Business
Amenities:
Serves alcoholOffers outdoor seatingGood for groups

76. Jobs Lane Gastro Pub

Jobs Lane Gastro Pub

10 Windmill Ln, Southampton, NY, 11968

CLOSED NOW
YP
18 Years
in Business

77. Scotto's Pork Store

Scotto's Pork Store

25 W Montauk Hwy, Hampton Bays, NY, 11946

CLOSED NOW
YP
15 Years
in Business
Amenities:
Offers outdoor seatingGood for groups

78. Manna Restaurant

Manna Restaurant

73 Foster Ave, Hampton Bays, NY, 11946

Amenities:
Wheelchair accessible

79. Teddy's Old Lyme Pizza Palace

Teddy's Old Lyme Pizza Palace

264 Shore Rd, Old Lyme, CT, 06371

CLOSED NOW
YP
35 Years
in Business
Amenities:
Has WifiServes alcoholWheelchair accessible

80. Paesan's Pizza

Paesan's Pizza

1550 Boston Post Rd, Old Saybrook, CT, 06475

CLOSED NOW
YP
34 Years
in Business
Amenities:
Offers outdoor seatingGood for groups

81. Parthenon Diner-Old Saybrook

Parthenon Diner-Old Saybrook

809 Boston Post Rd, Old Saybrook, CT, 06475

OPEN NOW:6:00 am - 11:30 pm
YP
10 Years
in Business
Amenities:
Has WifiServes alcoholWheelchair accessible

82. Francesc Restaurant

Francesc Restaurant

9 Ponquogue Ave, Hampton Bays, NY, 11946

OPEN NOW:11:00 am - 10:30 pm

"I highly recommend Francesca's. They are always so busy, but treat every customer like they are the only customer! The pizza is the best in town and the staff is always…"

YP
36 Years
in Business
Amenities:
Has WifiServes alcoholWheelchair accessible

83. Lenny's

Lenny's

1451 Main Rd, Jamesport, NY, 11947

CLOSED NOW

From Business: Lenny's Pizza and Pasta Of Jamesport, New York. Gourmet pizza and fine italian cuisine for lunch and dinner.

YP
26 Years
in Business

84. Sicilian Pizza & Pasta

Sicilian Pizza & Pasta

55 Route 48 Unit 2, Mattituck, NY, 11952

CLOSED NOW
YP
29 Years
in Business

85. Sal's Pizza & Pasta

Sal's Pizza & Pasta

29 Spencer Plain Rd, Old Saybrook, CT, 06475

CLOSED NOW

"Huge portions and a nice Italian smell to it. Very nice and I would definitely go there again"

YP
30 Years
in Business
Amenities:
Serves alcoholGood for groups