We used to go here regularly, and hadn't been in a while, but for our anniversary, I couldn't wait to have that AMAZING octopus and the awesome salad and sea bass again. Well, the octopus was NOT the same, VERY disappointing, cut and cooked differently than before, the FAMOUS salad had NO strawberries and just a few tiny chopped walnuts WHEN I could find them. The sea bass was done well, but the accompaniyng string bean veggies were NOT cooked correctly, apparently the new cook staff is not educated on exact al dente. And last but not least, the bill was jacked up at least by a third of what we used to pay for the exact orders we used to get. Next time, we will go to Ocean Prime or Ruth's Chris!! I want 5-STAR NOT 3-star for almost $200 for 2 people with just dinner, 4 drinks, 1 glass of wine and 2 "FREE" tiny desserts (for our anniversary)! Real shame they ruined what used to be a great experience, oh and let's not forget the comedy show of the table full of loud, vulgar trailer residents we had to suffer through wishing for a quiet, classy dining experience,... so much for that!!

Service and food was good. Price and value were bad. $16 stake was the size of a normal scallop. It could have been eaten in one bite. Then when my drink came, it was slightly bigger than a shot glass. I could've drank it in one sip. Cost $70 for two people with two entrées and three drinks. Smallish portions I've ever seen. Will not be returning.

This place is consistently good and is reasonably priced. Recommend it highly.

Had a craving for some seafood, and this was an exceptional place for me to satisfy my cravings. The food was great and the staff friendly and efficient.

Consistently great service and the food is to die for. My absolute favorite!

One of Tampabays Best Restaurants !! Excellent !!

Upscale atmosphere and really good food

My wife and I with friends have been to Mystic Fish over 10 times over the past 12 months. The service is always great. We always get seated within 5 minutes of our reservation time. The food is always delicious.