- Mozzarella Longboats$7.495 battered mozzarella sticks served golden brown with house-made marinara
- Chicken Fingers$8.295 huge chicken fingers served with your choice of bbq, honey mustard, blue cheese or ranch
- Pirate Potato Skins$7.594 baked potato skins, heaping with cheddar cheese and bacon, served with sour cream
- Spinach And Artichoke Scurvy Dip$7.99a bowl of creamy spinach and artichoke dip served with corn tortilla chips
- Bayside Chips$5.99hot crispy chips fried golden brown with a choice of plain, cajun or old bay seasoning
- Balsamic Vinaigrette, Creamy Blue Cheese, Crumbly Blue Cheese, French, Honey Mustard, Italian, 1000 Island, Ranch, Pepper Parmesan, Raspberry Vinaigrette
- The Captains Grilled SaladChicken: $8.99Steak: $9.99grilled marinated chicken or steak served atop a bed of greens with tomatoes, cheddar cheese, garlic croutons and your choice of dressing
- New World Greens$3.49crisp greens with tomatoes and garlic croutons with your choice of dressing
- Landlubber Clam ChowderCup: $4.59Bowl: $5.49a sodus point favorite - house made!
- Soup Of The MomentCup: $3.99Bowl: $4.99its just that...hot and fresh
- All Entrees Served With Choice Of Two Sides, Roll And Butter
- 16oz Calypso Rib Eye Steak$19.99aged usda choice delmonico grilled to your liking, seasoned with your choice of montreal, cajun, garlic butter or plain and topped with marinated mushrooms
- 14oz New York Strip Steak$17.99aged usda choice center cut strip steak grilled to your liking with choice of montreal, cajun, garlic butter or plain and topped with marinated mushrooms
- 11oz Black Beard Butcher Steak$14.99aged usda choice sirloin grilled to your liking with choice of montreal, cajun, garlic butter or plain and topped with marinated mushrooms
- Chicken Castaway$13.99two huge marinated chicken breasts topped with mushrooms, artichokes, roasted red peppers and swiss cheese
- Tropical Coconut Shrimp$13.998 jumbo coconut shrimp served golden brown with creamy orange horseradish dipping sauce
- Breaded Onion Rings$2.19
- Macaroni Salad$1.59
- Coleslaw$1.59
- Side Salad$2.29
- Vegetable Of The Day$1.59
- Breaded Onion Rings
- Macaroni Salad
- Coleslaw
- Side Salad
- Vegetable Of The Day