- everybody loves a big witch 1.5 oz of decadence
- Fat WitchEach (3.5 Oz): $2.95the original brownie with a moist intense chocolate taste
- Java WitchEach (3.5 Oz): $2.95original with cappuccino chocolate chips
- Blonde WitchEach (3.8 Oz): $2.95like a chocolate chip cookie in a brownie form
- Red WitchEach (3.5 Oz): $2.95the original with dried cherries inside
- Snow WitchEach (3.5 Oz): $2.95all white chocolate brownie
- Caramel WitchEach (4 Oz): $2.95the original a layer of caramel inside
- Breakfast WitchEach (6 Oz): $2.95oatmeal walnut and coffee on a little bit of brownie
- Fat Witch WalnutEach (3.8 Oz): $2.95the original baked with walnuts
- everybody loves a witch baby
- Fat Witch BabyEach (1.5 Oz): $1.85the original brownie with a moist intense chocolate taste
- Blonde BabyEach (1.5 Oz): $1.85like a chocolate chip cookie in a brownie form
- Walnut BabyEach (1.5 Oz): $1.85the original baked with walnuts
- Cauldron Special$21.00the perfect way to say thank you. 6 fat witch babies. 6 blonde babies in a take-out box with ribbon
- Cookie Witch$28.0024 chocolate chip cookies in a witch tin
- Witch Brew$8.99tiny bits of real chocolate melt into making the best hot chocolate ever
- Fat Witch Bag$6.95eco-friendly tote bag featuring the fat witch logo
- Fat Witch Logo Mug$10.95it's a mug to remember new york
- Fat Witch Magnet$2.50rubberized 2 1/2" square, perfect on the refrigerator