- Create Your Own CreationLike It: $5.25Love It: $5.75Gotta Have It: $6.50Select your choice of ice cream, sorbet or yogurt flavor and 1 free mix-in. Customize further by adding more mix-ins and a waffle cone or bowl. Choose a ice cream: Boo Batter Ice Cream, Chocolate Ice Cream, French Vanilla Ice Cream, Strawberry Ice Cream, Cake Batter Ice Cream.
- Mario's Super Birthday BlastLike It: $6.25Love It: $6.75Gotta Have It: $7.50Mine (Pint): $8.75Ours (Quart): $10.00Everybody's (Triple Pint): $15.00Cake batter ice cream with yellow cake, bright blue frosting and star sprinkles. Served in a special-edition cup featuring mario when you order the gotta have it size while supplies last.
- Choose a ice cream: Boo Batter Ice Cream, Chocolate Ice Cream, French Vanilla Ice Cream, Strawberry Ice Cream, Cake Batter Ice Cream.
- Mix And Go Create Your Own Creation Mine (Pint)$8.75Select your choice of ice cream, sorbet or yogurt flavor and free mix-ins. Customize further by adding more mix-ins and take it home to enjoy.
- Mix And Go Create Your Own Creation Ours (Quart)$10.00Select your choice of ice cream, sorbet or yogurt flavor and free mix-ins. Customize further by adding more mix-ins and take it home to enjoy.
- Create Your Own ShakeLike It: $5.75Love It: $6.75Select your choice of ice cream or yogurt flavor and 1 free mix-in. Customize further by adding more mix-ins!. Choose a ice cream: Boo Batter Ice Cream, Chocolate Ice Cream, French Vanilla Ice Cream, Strawberry Ice Cream, Cake Batter Ice Cream.
- Mario's Super Star ShakeLike It: $5.75Love It: $6.75Cake batter ice cream and bright blue frosting topped with whipped topping and star sprinkles.
- Choose a special messaging: Happy Birthday, Feliz CumpleaƱos, Happy Father's Day, Merry Christmas, Best Wishes. Choose a special messaging color: Red Writing, Blue Writing, White Writing, Yellow Writing, Purple Writing.
- Cake Batter Confetti6" Small Round (Serves up To 8): $29.008" Large Round (Serves up To 14): $39.00Layers of moist red velvet cake and cake batter ice cream with rainbow sprinkles wrapped in fluffy white frosting.
- Coffeehouse Crunch4" Petite (Serves up To 2) - 2 Layers: $14.006" Small Round (Serves up To 8): $29.008" Large Round (Serves up To 14): $39.008" X 12" Small Rectangle (Serves up To 25): $61.0012" X 18" Large Rectangle (Serves up To 40) - 2 Layers: $71.00Layers of moist devil's food cake and coffee ice cream with heath bar wrapped in rich fudge ganache.
- Choose a frosting: Fluffy White Frosting, Fluffy Pink Frosting.
- Diy 6-pack Ice Cream Cupcake Kit$21.506 rich chocolate cups filled with moist cake (2 of each yellow cake, red velvet cake and devil's food cake) and ice cream (2 of each sweet cream, cake batter and chocolate ice cream) ready to decorate with an included bag of frosting and mix-ins to top them off.
- Bottled Water$2.00