My girlfriend got me hooked on the place. The first thing I look for in a restaurant is a friendly wait staff. Bynum's, in my opinion, is exceptional in this regard. Jeffrey is my usual waiter, but the others are outstanding as well. I am a soup and sandwich kind of guy and my girlfriend LOVES their prime rib! I highly recommend their bleu cheese burger (actually any burger on the lunch menu) and any of their soups. The atmosphere is wonderful and usually quiet. They have become a regular stop for me whenever I am in Indianapolis.

The prime rib is unbelievable i don't know anyone who could eat the whole thing! 32 OZ! The lobster tails are huge too. Steaks are unbelievable! Good prices considering you get French Onion soup, & salad & bread INCLUDED with your gigantic entree. The prime rib you can share it is so huge. It is one of my most favorite places to eat. I also like the fact it is a privately owned LOCAL restaurant and not a chain. I always try to support our own local Indianapolis businesses when I can!

1st visit staff was very abrupt and rude. Took a long time to take our order and a ling time to get it. Food not cooked the way we ordered. Never offered refill on our drinks. Returned one year later hoping it got better. I ordered fish and after waiting over 30 minutes for it, it wasn't even cooked. The server asked if I wanted it sent back and told her no, biting into the uncooked fish turned my stomach and I lost my taste for it. Never offered anything in it's place but she took a whopping $2 off our order. My husband's steak wasn't real tasty either. I'm not sure what the draw here is there are much better steak places in this city. I have noticed less cars there than there use to be. Bad Bad Bad!

The atmosphere was exceptional. The personnel waiting tables were personable and courteous. The orders were delivered correctly and were of very high quality. I would recommend this steak house to anyone. The price was reasonable for what was received.