My family has had reunions and other events catered by Club 86 (there are two in Geneva), and every time I am in town, my children beg me to bring them some fresh baked cookies from Club 86 each morning. I am more than happy to pick up their cookies, and enjoy a fresh cup of coffee in the outdoor seating area before heading back to my nearby lodging. I visit Geneva each summer for a week at minimum, and along with the wonderful food, pastries, and coffee they have wireless internet access that is invaluable to us while we're away. I am not sure which Club 86 is on Hamilton Street, but my family has had receptions and catering jobs through both and we were equally satisfied. One is more of a reception hall, and the other is a smaller cafe on routes 5&20 with outdoor seating and lots of other stores and shopping areas close by. There are other coffee shops in the area, but Club 86 is less commercial, has easier parking access, and is my local favorite for any time of day.