We apologize for the inconvenience

The people search feature on Superpages.com is temporarily unavailable. You can still search for people on yellowpages.com since Yellow Pages and Superpages are part of one company.

You will be automatically re-directed to People Search on yellowpages.com in .

Mustachio's Pizzeria

Add to Favorites
Write a Review!
Italian Restaurants, American Restaurants, Caterers

2701 Elmwood Ave, Buffalo, NY 14217


Today: 11:00 am - 11:00 pm

REVIEWS write reviewWrite a Review


  • 5star
  • 4star
  • 3star
  • 2star
  • 1star
5 Reviews
Rate this business!
First-classBetter than mostAbout what I expectedNot the worst...Disappointing


New to New York and today had my first real slice of pizza. It was soooo good. Just like the oversized, floppy crusted, stringy cheesy pizza you see in movies, this was everything I imagined and more. No more big chain restaurant pizza for me. Service was also great. I will definitely go back.

Was this Review helpful to you?0


Definitely would not recommend. i ordered a chicken finger dinner (which is 7.95) and the fingers are tiny, definitely not living up to buffalos reputation for hugs chicken fingers (everywhere else we go) very disappointing. tried them one more time since the last time they argued with me over not delivering one of my items. took 10 minutes of arguing with girl on phone then they delivered my cold food another half hour later. very unimpressed and will not be ordering there again. save your $$!!

Was this Review helpful to you?0
Jennifer Klima


Super tasty pizza! The basic pepperoni is greasy and terrific!! The subs there are some of the best around- I quite enjoy their italian sausage sub!

Was this Review helpful to you?0


review count1photo count0
Best of...

oh my goodness - the very best turkey club i've had!!! We have been there 3 times and each time was fantastic!

Was this Review helpful to you?0


review count1photo count0
Best of...take out fish fry

After years of looking for a consistant "good" fish fry, we have finally found the place. Homemade salads, large portions, and just plain yummy! A must try!

Was this Review helpful to you?0
General Info
We're Right Under Your Nose! Since 1989 Mustachio's Pizza has been serving Kenmore, Tonawanda, North Buffalo, Riverside, and Black Rock all of their favorite Italian dishes including our famous pizzas! We love catering for large & special events.
Regular Hours
Mon - Thu:
Fri - Sat:
Italian Restaurants, American Restaurants, Caterers, Pizza, Restaurants, Take Out Restaurants
Boneless Wings Calzones Chicken Fingers Chicken Wings Cold Cut Subs Deli Sandwiches Dinners Hot Sandwiches Hot Subs Pizza Salads Sides Soups Specialty Pizza Strombolis Super Hoagies Tacos Wraps
Payment Options
Price Range
Kenmore, Kenmore NW
Other Information

Parking: Lot, Private

Wi-Fi: No

Attire: Casual

Good For Groups: Yes

Good for Kids: Yes

Wheelchair Accessible: Yes

Take Out: Yes

Cuisines: Italian, European, Continental, Pizza

Alcohol: No

Bike Parking: Yes

Takes Reservations: No

Outdoor Seating: No

Specialties: Special Orders, Birthday Party Orders, Large Group Orders, Holiday Party Orders

Price Range : Average

Provided by
Data provided by one or more of the following: Thryv, Data Axle, Yext.