Please note our privacy policy has changed. To view the policy, please go to https://corporate.thryv.com/privacy/

Details
Contact Us Now
HoursCLOSED NOW
Regular Hours:
MonClosed
Tue - Sat
SunClosed

Contact Info

Phone:

Main - 716-907-6778

Address:
57 Main St Akron, NY 14001
Email:

Reviews

5
31 Reviews
Select your rating
Write a Review
Pat W.

07/01/25

Provided by Thryv
5.0

The cookies were beautiful and everyone enjoyed them!

Was this Review helpful to you?0
Lynn O.

06/28/25

Provided by Thryv
5.0

Absolutely loved the cookies that were made to celebrate our graduate. They were adorable and delicious too!

Was this Review helpful to you?0
Pat T.

06/25/25

Provided by Thryv
5.0

They are amazing. Made the exact cookies my four year old granddaughter wanted for her birthday. Also friendly and very helpful. Highly recommend this company!

Was this Review helpful to you?0
Nicole C.

06/20/25

Provided by Thryv
5.0

The cassata cake was very delicious. We had many compliments about it and would definitely purchase again! Thank you

Was this Review helpful to you?0
Kimberly S.

06/10/25

Provided by Thryv
5.0

Needed custom cookies for an event and they were able to accommodate my request. The price is excellent and they come wrapped for no extra cost!

Was this Review helpful to you?0
Lynn Z.

05/19/25

Provided by Thryv
5.0

Excellent in every way!! My daughter wanted a mango or raspberry flavored cake for her 18th Birthday this year. She was able to have both flavors for her cake; it was excellent and decorated beautifully with a palm tree like I asked for.

Was this Review helpful to you?0
Kimberly Z.

05/18/25

Provided by Thryv
5.0

It was delicious!! Thank you!

Was this Review helpful to you?0
Paula J.

05/11/25

Provided by Thryv
5.0

No matter what we've ordered from Sugarmamas from her cinnamon buns, scones or her hand pies(my favorite) they are always delicious!!

Was this Review helpful to you?0
Jaylene S.

04/26/25

Provided by Thryv
5.0

From start to finish, my experience with Sugarmama Bakeshop was excellent. Taking the order, payment & pick up everything was smooth & easy. The cookies were absolutely delicious and exceeded my expectations. The cookies were for a Retirement Party & everyone was very pleased with them. I highly recommend Sugarmama's Bakeshop, a definite 5 Star experience & I will be ordering again for sure!

Was this Review helpful to you?0
Hilary B.

04/13/25

Provided by Thryv
5.0

Andrea was warm and welcoming when we came in for our initial wedding consultation. She has an amazing array of options for cake flavors and frosting to choose from. Her buttercream was absolutely the best I've ever tasted! Highly recommend!

Was this Review helpful to you?0
Mellysa K.

03/23/25

Provided by Thryv
5.0

Cake is super yummy and the customer service was great! Everyone was raving about the cake throughout the whole party!

Was this Review helpful to you?0
Jill O.

02/12/25

Provided by Thryv
5.0

The cake was delicious and beautiful! We love ordering from here! Service is great and very responsive!

Was this Review helpful to you?0
Jill P.

01/19/25

Provided by Thryv
5.0

The experience of placing an order, and securing the delivery and details has been effortless. I was able to speak with the owner, Andie who assured me all details will be taken care of. I look forward to using Sugarmama's again!

Was this Review helpful to you?0
Sue G.

12/15/24

Provided by Thryv
5.0

i have not yet tasted the Christmas cookies but as far as the ordering process everything was so easy and we were able to pick the cookies we wanted in our tray and that made a difference to us because the grandkids only like certain kind. Thank you, again!

Was this Review helpful to you?0
Gina L.

11/23/24

Provided by Thryv
5.0

Ordered cookies for my Dads 80th Birthday and sugar mama exceeded my expectations with these cookies!! Amazing and the taste great!!

Was this Review helpful to you?0
Rebecca K.

11/18/24

Provided by Thryv
5.0

I haven't sampled Sugarmama's bakery items yet but they come highly recommended. I have some orders in for the holidays and a baby shower. Dealing with Andie the owner has been a wonderful experience.
Andie is very easy to deal with and makes the experience special. Look

Rebecca Kraus

Was this Review helpful to you?0
Stevie R.

09/30/24

Provided by Thryv
5.0

I was very happy with my whole experience with Sugarmama’s. From placing my order, to paying, and pick up, everything was easy and went smoothly. And the cake was delicious! Exactly what I was looking for. Would recommend 100%!

Was this Review helpful to you?0
Danuta V.

08/31/24

Provided by Thryv
5.0

Beautiful cake to celebrate my husband getting his green card and new job at Netflix!! The flavors were so delicious and the design was beautiful!

Was this Review helpful to you?0
Nicole S.

08/21/24

Provided by Thryv
5.0

The owner was responsive and asked for pictures of my twin girls dresses so she could match the colors to their first birthday photo shoot smash cakes. She was pleasant to deal with and I will be ordering both cakes for their first birthday party from her as well.

Was this Review helpful to you?0
Anna Kate B.

08/11/24

Provided by Thryv
5.0

Lovely to communicate with, great service, beautiful designed cookies and fairly priced! I will definitely use Sugaramamas again.

Was this Review helpful to you?0
Categories
Pies, Bakeries, Dessert Restaurants, Food Products, Restaurants
Payment Options
amex, cash, master card, visa
Provided by
Data provided by one or more of the following: Thryv, Data Axle, Yext.